EVENT>Thursday Afternoon Pairs |SESSION>Thursday Aft |SECTION> A N-S ------------------------,------ ------------,-------- -------------------------- DATE>April 6, 2017 |SANCTION>OS1704123 | 04/06/2017 16:10|EVENT CODE>9999 ---------------------,-- ------------------- -------------,--------------------- DIR> Fred Strong |RATING>Inter Club Championship (100%, 80%, 70% Open), CLUB>241919|MOVEMENT>MITCHELL ------------,-------- ,-------------------------,--------- --------------------- AVE> 84.0 |TOP> 6 |MP LIMITS>None/500/200 |CLUB>North County Duplicate Br ------------ --------- ------------------------- ------------------------------- PAIRS IN STRAT A=8/B=4/C=1 ,---,-------------------------,------,---------, -------------------------------------------------| | Section | |Section | No Name Name |Flt|Rnk-A|Rnk-B|Rnk-C| Score | Pct |Awards | ------------------------------------------------- --- ----- ----- ----- ------- ------ --------- 1 Gene Edgerton Pamela Nargie B . . . 77.42 46.08 2 Floyd Redman Betty Hsu A 1 . . 97.33 57.93 0.80(A) 3 Anita Williamson Dell Wilson A . . . 82.31 48.99 4 Grant Morgan Sue Morgan A 2 . . 96.06 57.18 0.56(A) 6 Gretchen Bassett Fred Strong B 3 1 . 84.32 50.19 0.40(A) 7 Warren Conklin Paul Harwood C . . . 70.32 41.86 8 Elizabeth Helgerson Ronald Helgerson B . 2 . 80.16 47.71 0.22(B) Totals 587.92 EVENT>Thursday Afternoon Pairs |SESSION>Thursday Aft |SECTION> A E-W ------------------------,------ ------------,-------- -------------------------- DATE>April 6, 2017 |SANCTION>OS1704123 | 04/06/2017 16:10|EVENT CODE>9999 ---------------------,-- ------------------- -------------,--------------------- DIR> Fred Strong |RATING>Inter Club Championship (100%, 80%, 70% Open), CLUB>241919|MOVEMENT>MITCHELL ------------,-------- ,-------------------------,--------- --------------------- AVE> 84.0 |TOP> 6 |MP LIMITS>None/500/200 |CLUB>North County Duplicate Br ------------ --------- ------------------------- ------------------------------- PAIRS IN STRAT A=8/B=7/C=5 ,---,-------------------------,------,---------, -------------------------------------------------| | Section | |Section | No Name Name |Flt|Rnk-A|Rnk-B|Rnk-C| Score | Pct |Awards | ------------------------------------------------- --- ----- ----- ----- ------- ------ --------- 1 Theresa Gillette Kathleen Giachino C . . . 71.42 42.51 2 Doris Murfee Von Barge Lieselotte Stockmann C . . . 69.60 41.43 3 Ellen Frost Steven Festa B 1 1 . 99.39 59.16 0.80(A) 4 Mike McGlothin Mary Beigel C . . . 82.83 49.30 5 Pat Johnson Lillian Disandro C . . 2 84.70 50.42 0.25(C) 6 Stuart Baron Mickey Peaslee A . . . 82.85 49.32 7 Marvin Segar Jim Parks B 3 3 . 87.05 51.82 0.40(A) 8 David Gillette Mike Hughes C 2 2 1 96.36 57.36 0.56(A) Totals 674.20 RESULTS OF BOARD 1 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 140 5.92 0.08 1-Edgerton-Nargie vs 1-Gillette-Giachino 170 3.58 2.42 3-Williamson-Wilson vs 4-McGlothin-Beigel 170 3.58 2.42 4-Morgan-Morgan vs 6-Baron-Peaslee 420 1.25 4.75 6-Bassett-Strong vs 3-Frost-Festa 450 0.08 5.92 7-Conklin-Harwood vs 5-Johnson-Disandro 170 3.58 2.42 8-Helgerson-Helgerson vs 7-Segar-Parks ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 2 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 680 4.75 1.25 1-Edgerton-Nargie vs 1-Gillette-Giachino 680 4.75 1.25 3-Williamson-Wilson vs 4-McGlothin-Beigel 680 4.75 1.25 4-Morgan-Morgan vs 6-Baron-Peaslee 100 1.83 4.17 6-Bassett-Strong vs 3-Frost-Festa 100 1.83 4.17 7-Conklin-Harwood vs 5-Johnson-Disandro 200 0.08 5.92 8-Helgerson-Helgerson vs 7-Segar-Parks ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 3 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 100 4.75 1.25 1-Edgerton-Nargie vs 1-Gillette-Giachino 800 0.08 5.92 3-Williamson-Wilson vs 4-McGlothin-Beigel 300 5.92 0.08 4-Morgan-Morgan vs 6-Baron-Peaslee 50 3.00 3.00 6-Bassett-Strong vs 3-Frost-Festa 150 1.25 4.75 7-Conklin-Harwood vs 5-Johnson-Disandro 50 3.00 3.00 8-Helgerson-Helgerson vs 7-Segar-Parks ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 4 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 620 2.42 3.58 1-Edgerton-Nargie vs 1-Gillette-Giachino 100 5.33 0.67 3-Williamson-Wilson vs 4-McGlothin-Beigel 100 5.33 0.67 4-Morgan-Morgan vs 6-Baron-Peaslee 650 0.08 5.92 6-Bassett-Strong vs 3-Frost-Festa 620 2.42 3.58 7-Conklin-Harwood vs 5-Johnson-Disandro 620 2.42 3.58 8-Helgerson-Helgerson vs 7-Segar-Parks ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 5 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 630 5.33 0.67 1-Edgerton-Nargie vs 8-Gillette-Hughes 600 1.83 4.17 2-Redman-Hsu vs 2-Von Bargen-Stockmann 620 3.58 2.42 4-Morgan-Morgan vs 5-Johnson-Disandro 600 1.83 4.17 6-Bassett-Strong vs 1-Gillette-Giachino 630 5.33 0.67 7-Conklin-Harwood vs 4-McGlothin-Beigel 100 0.08 5.92 8-Helgerson-Helgerson vs 6-Baron-Peaslee ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 6 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 140 0.08 5.92 1-Edgerton-Nargie vs 8-Gillette-Hughes 460 5.92 0.08 2-Redman-Hsu vs 2-Von Bargen-Stockmann 420 3.58 2.42 4-Morgan-Morgan vs 5-Johnson-Disandro 430 4.75 1.25 6-Bassett-Strong vs 1-Gillette-Giachino 400 2.42 3.58 7-Conklin-Harwood vs 4-McGlothin-Beigel 210 1.25 4.75 8-Helgerson-Helgerson vs 6-Baron-Peaslee ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 7 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 110 0.08 5.92 1-Edgerton-Nargie vs 8-Gillette-Hughes 140 3.00 3.00 2-Redman-Hsu vs 2-Von Bargen-Stockmann 140 3.00 3.00 4-Morgan-Morgan vs 5-Johnson-Disandro 140 3.00 3.00 6-Bassett-Strong vs 1-Gillette-Giachino 630 5.92 0.08 7-Conklin-Harwood vs 4-McGlothin-Beigel 140 3.00 3.00 8-Helgerson-Helgerson vs 6-Baron-Peaslee ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 8 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 110 0.08 5.92 1-Edgerton-Nargie vs 8-Gillette-Hughes 500 5.92 0.08 2-Redman-Hsu vs 2-Von Bargen-Stockmann 100 1.83 4.17 4-Morgan-Morgan vs 5-Johnson-Disandro 150 3.58 2.42 6-Bassett-Strong vs 1-Gillette-Giachino 200 4.75 1.25 7-Conklin-Harwood vs 4-McGlothin-Beigel 100 1.83 4.17 8-Helgerson-Helgerson vs 6-Baron-Peaslee ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 9 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 660 3.00 3.00 1-Edgerton-Nargie vs 7-Segar-Parks 100 5.33 0.67 2-Redman-Hsu vs 1-Gillette-Giachino 690 0.67 5.33 3-Williamson-Wilson vs 3-Frost-Festa 690 0.67 5.33 6-Bassett-Strong vs 8-Gillette-Hughes 660 3.00 3.00 7-Conklin-Harwood vs 2-Von Bargen-Stockmann 100 5.33 0.67 8-Helgerson-Helgerson vs 5-Johnson-Disandro ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 10 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 690 1.25 4.75 1-Edgerton-Nargie vs 7-Segar-Parks 630 4.75 1.25 2-Redman-Hsu vs 1-Gillette-Giachino 680 3.58 2.42 3-Williamson-Wilson vs 3-Frost-Festa 690 1.25 4.75 6-Bassett-Strong vs 8-Gillette-Hughes 100 5.92 0.08 7-Conklin-Harwood vs 2-Von Bargen-Stockmann 690 1.25 4.75 8-Helgerson-Helgerson vs 5-Johnson-Disandro ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 11 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 100 4.75 1.25 1-Edgerton-Nargie vs 7-Segar-Parks 50 1.25 4.75 2-Redman-Hsu vs 1-Gillette-Giachino 50 1.25 4.75 3-Williamson-Wilson vs 3-Frost-Festa 100 4.75 1.25 6-Bassett-Strong vs 8-Gillette-Hughes 100 4.75 1.25 7-Conklin-Harwood vs 2-Von Bargen-Stockmann 50 1.25 4.75 8-Helgerson-Helgerson vs 5-Johnson-Disandro ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 12 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 450 0.08 5.92 1-Edgerton-Nargie vs 7-Segar-Parks 200 2.42 3.58 2-Redman-Hsu vs 1-Gillette-Giachino 180 3.58 2.42 3-Williamson-Wilson vs 3-Frost-Festa 420 1.25 4.75 6-Bassett-Strong vs 8-Gillette-Hughes 150 4.75 1.25 7-Conklin-Harwood vs 2-Von Bargen-Stockmann 110 5.92 0.08 8-Helgerson-Helgerson vs 5-Johnson-Disandro ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 13 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 620 0.00 6.00 1-Edgerton-Nargie vs 6-Baron-Peaslee 170 2.00 4.00 2-Redman-Hsu vs 8-Gillette-Hughes 140 4.00 2.00 3-Williamson-Wilson vs 2-Von Bargen-Stockmann 140 4.00 2.00 4-Morgan-Morgan vs 4-McGlothin-Beigel 140 4.00 2.00 6-Bassett-Strong vs 7-Segar-Parks 400 1.00 5.00 7-Conklin-Harwood vs 1-Gillette-Giachino 100 6.00 0.00 8-Helgerson-Helgerson vs 3-Frost-Festa ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 14 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 100 3.00 3.00 1-Edgerton-Nargie vs 6-Baron-Peaslee 130 6.00 0.00 2-Redman-Hsu vs 8-Gillette-Hughes 90 2.00 4.00 3-Williamson-Wilson vs 2-Von Bargen-Stockmann 50 1.00 5.00 4-Morgan-Morgan vs 4-McGlothin-Beigel 110 4.50 1.50 6-Bassett-Strong vs 7-Segar-Parks 50 0.00 6.00 7-Conklin-Harwood vs 1-Gillette-Giachino 110 4.50 1.50 8-Helgerson-Helgerson vs 3-Frost-Festa ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 15 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 150 4.50 1.50 1-Edgerton-Nargie vs 6-Baron-Peaslee 50 6.00 0.00 2-Redman-Hsu vs 8-Gillette-Hughes 150 4.50 1.50 3-Williamson-Wilson vs 2-Von Bargen-Stockmann 400 1.00 5.00 4-Morgan-Morgan vs 4-McGlothin-Beigel 400 1.00 5.00 6-Bassett-Strong vs 7-Segar-Parks 170 3.00 3.00 7-Conklin-Harwood vs 1-Gillette-Giachino 400 1.00 5.00 8-Helgerson-Helgerson vs 3-Frost-Festa ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 16 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 200 5.50 0.50 1-Edgerton-Nargie vs 6-Baron-Peaslee 200 5.50 0.50 2-Redman-Hsu vs 8-Gillette-Hughes 100 1.00 5.00 3-Williamson-Wilson vs 2-Von Bargen-Stockmann 500 0.00 6.00 4-Morgan-Morgan vs 4-McGlothin-Beigel 100 4.00 2.00 6-Bassett-Strong vs 7-Segar-Parks 90 2.50 3.50 7-Conklin-Harwood vs 1-Gillette-Giachino 90 2.50 3.50 8-Helgerson-Helgerson vs 3-Frost-Festa ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 17 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 450 0.67 5.33 1-Edgerton-Nargie vs 4-McGlothin-Beigel 170 3.58 2.42 2-Redman-Hsu vs 7-Segar-Parks 50 5.33 0.67 3-Williamson-Wilson vs 1-Gillette-Giachino 50 5.33 0.67 4-Morgan-Morgan vs 3-Frost-Festa 420 2.42 3.58 7-Conklin-Harwood vs 8-Gillette-Hughes 450 0.67 5.33 8-Helgerson-Helgerson vs 2-Von Bargen-Stockmann ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 18 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 100 3.00 3.00 1-Edgerton-Nargie vs 4-McGlothin-Beigel 300 5.92 0.08 2-Redman-Hsu vs 7-Segar-Parks 100 0.08 5.92 3-Williamson-Wilson vs 1-Gillette-Giachino 50 1.25 4.75 4-Morgan-Morgan vs 3-Frost-Festa 100 3.00 3.00 7-Conklin-Harwood vs 8-Gillette-Hughes 140 4.75 1.25 8-Helgerson-Helgerson vs 2-Von Bargen-Stockmann ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 19 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 110 2.42 3.58 1-Edgerton-Nargie vs 4-McGlothin-Beigel 170 5.33 0.67 2-Redman-Hsu vs 7-Segar-Parks 140 3.58 2.42 3-Williamson-Wilson vs 1-Gillette-Giachino 170 5.33 0.67 4-Morgan-Morgan vs 3-Frost-Festa 380 0.08 5.92 7-Conklin-Harwood vs 8-Gillette-Hughes 50 1.25 4.75 8-Helgerson-Helgerson vs 2-Von Bargen-Stockmann ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 20 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 1100 5.92 0.08 1-Edgerton-Nargie vs 4-McGlothin-Beigel 100 3.58 2.42 2-Redman-Hsu vs 7-Segar-Parks 100 1.83 4.17 3-Williamson-Wilson vs 1-Gillette-Giachino 120 0.08 5.92 4-Morgan-Morgan vs 3-Frost-Festa 200 4.75 1.25 7-Conklin-Harwood vs 8-Gillette-Hughes 100 1.83 4.17 8-Helgerson-Helgerson vs 2-Von Bargen-Stockmann ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 21 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 170 2.42 3.58 1-Edgerton-Nargie vs 3-Frost-Festa 100 0.67 5.33 2-Redman-Hsu vs 5-Johnson-Disandro 100 0.67 5.33 3-Williamson-Wilson vs 8-Gillette-Hughes 200 4.17 1.83 4-Morgan-Morgan vs 2-Von Bargen-Stockmann 500 5.92 0.08 6-Bassett-Strong vs 6-Baron-Peaslee 200 4.17 1.83 8-Helgerson-Helgerson vs 1-Gillette-Giachino ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 22 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 170 2.42 3.58 1-Edgerton-Nargie vs 3-Frost-Festa 170 2.42 3.58 2-Redman-Hsu vs 5-Johnson-Disandro 170 2.42 3.58 3-Williamson-Wilson vs 8-Gillette-Hughes 200 4.75 1.25 4-Morgan-Morgan vs 2-Von Bargen-Stockmann 140 0.08 5.92 6-Bassett-Strong vs 6-Baron-Peaslee 430 5.92 0.08 8-Helgerson-Helgerson vs 1-Gillette-Giachino ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 23 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 170 0.08 5.92 1-Edgerton-Nargie vs 3-Frost-Festa 130 3.00 3.00 2-Redman-Hsu vs 5-Johnson-Disandro 150 1.25 4.75 3-Williamson-Wilson vs 8-Gillette-Hughes 130 3.00 3.00 4-Morgan-Morgan vs 2-Von Bargen-Stockmann 100 4.75 1.25 6-Bassett-Strong vs 6-Baron-Peaslee 200 5.92 0.08 8-Helgerson-Helgerson vs 1-Gillette-Giachino ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 24 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 430 1.25 4.75 1-Edgerton-Nargie vs 3-Frost-Festa 430 1.25 4.75 2-Redman-Hsu vs 5-Johnson-Disandro 130 5.92 0.08 3-Williamson-Wilson vs 8-Gillette-Hughes 400 3.58 2.42 4-Morgan-Morgan vs 2-Von Bargen-Stockmann 430 1.25 4.75 6-Bassett-Strong vs 6-Baron-Peaslee 200 4.75 1.25 8-Helgerson-Helgerson vs 1-Gillette-Giachino ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 25 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 140 4.17 1.83 1-Edgerton-Nargie vs 2-Von Bargen-Stockmann 50 1.83 4.17 2-Redman-Hsu vs 4-McGlothin-Beigel 140 4.17 1.83 3-Williamson-Wilson vs 6-Baron-Peaslee 50 1.83 4.17 4-Morgan-Morgan vs 1-Gillette-Giachino 200 5.92 0.08 6-Bassett-Strong vs 5-Johnson-Disandro 620 0.08 5.92 7-Conklin-Harwood vs 7-Segar-Parks ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 26 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 110 2.42 3.58 1-Edgerton-Nargie vs 2-Von Bargen-Stockmann 110 2.42 3.58 2-Redman-Hsu vs 4-McGlothin-Beigel 140 5.92 0.08 3-Williamson-Wilson vs 6-Baron-Peaslee 110 2.42 3.58 4-Morgan-Morgan vs 1-Gillette-Giachino 120 4.75 1.25 6-Bassett-Strong vs 5-Johnson-Disandro 90 0.08 5.92 7-Conklin-Harwood vs 7-Segar-Parks ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 27 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 50 3.58 2.42 1-Edgerton-Nargie vs 2-Von Bargen-Stockmann 400 0.08 5.92 2-Redman-Hsu vs 4-McGlothin-Beigel 150 1.83 4.17 3-Williamson-Wilson vs 6-Baron-Peaslee 100 5.92 0.08 4-Morgan-Morgan vs 1-Gillette-Giachino 50 4.75 1.25 6-Bassett-Strong vs 5-Johnson-Disandro 150 1.83 4.17 7-Conklin-Harwood vs 7-Segar-Parks ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 28 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 50 3.58 2.42 1-Edgerton-Nargie vs 2-Von Bargen-Stockmann 100 5.92 0.08 2-Redman-Hsu vs 4-McGlothin-Beigel 120 1.25 4.75 3-Williamson-Wilson vs 6-Baron-Peaslee 50 3.58 2.42 4-Morgan-Morgan vs 1-Gillette-Giachino 50 3.58 2.42 6-Bassett-Strong vs 5-Johnson-Disandro 150 0.08 5.92 7-Conklin-Harwood vs 7-Segar-Parks ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 29 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 100 1.25 4.75 2-Redman-Hsu vs 3-Frost-Festa 90 3.58 2.42 3-Williamson-Wilson vs 5-Johnson-Disandro 170 4.75 1.25 4-Morgan-Morgan vs 7-Segar-Parks 100 1.25 4.75 6-Bassett-Strong vs 4-McGlothin-Beigel 300 5.92 0.08 7-Conklin-Harwood vs 6-Baron-Peaslee 100 1.25 4.75 8-Helgerson-Helgerson vs 8-Gillette-Hughes ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 30 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 100 3.58 2.42 2-Redman-Hsu vs 3-Frost-Festa 100 3.58 2.42 3-Williamson-Wilson vs 5-Johnson-Disandro 50 5.92 0.08 4-Morgan-Morgan vs 7-Segar-Parks 100 3.58 2.42 6-Bassett-Strong vs 4-McGlothin-Beigel 150 0.08 5.92 7-Conklin-Harwood vs 6-Baron-Peaslee 140 1.25 4.75 8-Helgerson-Helgerson vs 8-Gillette-Hughes ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 31 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 120 1.25 4.75 2-Redman-Hsu vs 3-Frost-Festa 50 5.33 0.67 3-Williamson-Wilson vs 5-Johnson-Disandro 90 3.58 2.42 4-Morgan-Morgan vs 7-Segar-Parks 110 2.42 3.58 6-Bassett-Strong vs 4-McGlothin-Beigel 140 0.08 5.92 7-Conklin-Harwood vs 6-Baron-Peaslee 50 5.33 0.67 8-Helgerson-Helgerson vs 8-Gillette-Hughes ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 32 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 200 5.33 0.67 2-Redman-Hsu vs 3-Frost-Festa PASS 1.25 4.75 3-Williamson-Wilson vs 5-Johnson-Disandro 100 3.00 3.00 4-Morgan-Morgan vs 7-Segar-Parks 200 5.33 0.67 6-Bassett-Strong vs 4-McGlothin-Beigel 100 3.00 3.00 7-Conklin-Harwood vs 6-Baron-Peaslee 120 0.08 5.92 8-Helgerson-Helgerson vs 8-Gillette-Hughes ----------------------------------------------------------------------